One of the most common questions we get this time of year is “Should I apply Early Decision?” As our November 1st Early Decision (ED) deadline approaches, many high school seniors are considering whether to make the binding commitment that goes along with applying ED. In this blog entry, we hope to provide some direction on how to tackle this important question and some advice on whether to ED or not to ED.
The first place to start is our Early Decision webpage to learn more about the process and for some straight forward answers. My best advice is to become familiar with how the ED agreement works, read about our two different ED plans, and decide whether you want to apply ED to Emory College, Oxford College, or both campuses. Now let’s focus on some of the key questions you should consider.
Who should apply Early Decision?
Simply put, if Emory University is your definitive first choice, and you are ready to make the commitment, then Early Decision is probably for you. The binding ED application plan is for students who definitely know that Emory is their first pick. This is for the students who have done their research, and for all the right reasons, they are confident in their decision. ED is for students who have fallen in love with our campus and our mission. If Emory is the school that you measure all other schools by, and those schools always fail in comparison, then we would strongly encourage you to consider ED.
Who should NOT apply Early Decision?
Perhaps this is obvious, but students who do not have a clear first choice school and want to weigh their options should not apply Early Decision to any school. Not everyone knows exactly what they want this early in their senior year, and that is 100% okay. Don’t ever feel forced to apply early somewhere, especially if you are someone who likes to take their time making a decision.
It’s important to consider financial aid as well. If you are admitted ED, you do not have the opportunity to compare financial aid offers from more than one university. If financial aid is a major factor in whether you can attend a university or not, then think carefully about whether you should apply ED or not. (See the next question for more info about how this works.)
We also recommend against applying ED for students who are only considering the binding commitment for tactical reasons. Students focused on just “getting in” and students who view applying ED solely as a strategic move, put simply, shouldn’t. Applying to colleges should not be seen as winning a game, and students who over-analyze statistical data about ED are approaching the process from the wrong direction. Selecting an ED admission plan should be about fit, 100% of the time.
Are there any disadvantages to apply ED?
If there is a disadvantage to applying ED, it has to do with financial aid. We use precisely the same methods for calculating eligibility for aid no matter what application plan you choose, but the disadvantage is that if you are admitted ED, you do not have the opportunity to compare financial aid offers from any other university. Each institution has its own way of determining how much a family can reasonably pay for college, and the outcome of that process is only revealed after you are offered admission. When admitted ED, you just get the one offer of financial aid from your ED institution. If you’re looking for the best financial aid package from multiple school offers, then consider this during your decision process.
Are there advantages to applying Early Decision?
Yes, there are definitely benefits to applying to ED. The earlier acceptance timeline is a clear advantage. ED applicants learn of their decision earlier. If admitted, their college search is complete, and they can focus on successfully finishing high school. If not admitted, though disappointing, students can move on and focus on other schools that would also be a good fit.
Another advantage is that during the ED evaluation process, Admission staff aren’t yet under the pressure of reading through hundreds and hundreds of applications. When the Admission Committee is evaluating applications during the early process, they have fewer applications overall to consider.
While the ED application pool is smaller, that does not mean there is a competitive advantage.
The phrase “competitive advantage” leads to a conclusion that it is easier to get in when applying ED. There are benefits to applying ED, but it is not easier to be admitted. The Admission Committee review process is the same during the early evaluation process as it is during the review of RD applicants—both in terms of academic metrics and holistic measures.
If I do not apply ED, do I still have a chance to be admitted?
We strive to hold at least half (if not more) of our admitted student spots for Regular Decision (RD) applicants. Students who apply RD are held to the same academic standards, and our admission evaluators are just as excited to read RD applications. Don’t feel forced to apply ED fearing that your application will be passed over. Great students are admitted during RD every year, and we would not have a complete class without our RD applicants!
Regardless of the application plan you choose, know that the Admission Committee desires to get to know you for who you really are through the application process. You can read more about how the Admission staff reviews your application by reading the Holistic Application Review blog. Feel free to share about what excites you, challenges you, drives you to go for broke and reach for more in the comments below. We hope your college aspirations lead you to Emory University, and please know we are here to assist you in the process.